"On one occasion, I went to a children's day fair and found myself sitting beside a rival politician. He was holding a stack of 100 baht notes to distribute to the children, while I had arrived empty-handed. How could I vie with that?"
Chutiphong Pipoppinyo was a member of the "idealistic tide" of idealistic young candidates who shocked Thailand in the 2023 election by winning more seats for the progressive Move Forward party than any other party.
However, in the latest election, he lost his seat in his home province of Rayong to a opponent from an old established family which has customarily held influential posts there.
"Back then we were similar to a gale that engulfed and the other parties could not fight back. They believed I was only a no-name candidate. The tide of support for Move Forward in the final stretch of that election genuinely persuaded voters to opt for a fresh alternative."
Now renamed the People's Party, their expectations that they would surpass their 2023 performance were shattered on the shoals of old-style clientelist systems which have governed provincial politics in Thailand across its contemporary era.
The tallies are still not official, and a several election anomalies are being investigated, but that will not alter the overall outcome: a sharp drop of over 20% in the total of seats gained by the People's Party, and a significant rise by the conservative Bhumjaithai party, increasing its share of seats from 71 in 2023 to an approximate 193 in the 500-seat parliament in the latest election.
'They never speak with me again'
Following gaining his seat in 2023, Chutiphong immersed himself in his role as MP, visiting his electoral area aiming to tackle the issues of his voters. But he swiftly met resistance from those working for the long-standing political operators. Worse still, he discovered he was pressured to provide financial support, from funds he just did not have.
"An invitation was extended to me to a women empowerment event - a common gathering for the residents to participate in and socialize. But they said if I wanted to come, I needed to give 25,000 baht. I told them I lacked that money. They were quite displeased about that and claimed I was stingy. I questioned if there was an alternative I could assist. But they never spoke to me afterwards."
What he had confronted was a entrenched framework of clientelism run by a particular family.
Rayong is most famous as part of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's biggest manufacturing hub, housing many of the factories which power its trade-reliant economy. This has brought in laborers from elsewhere from other regions, and also created an urban middle class which is more responsive to the progressive policies of the progressive movement.
In 2023, Move Forward swept all five constituencies there.
But much of Rayong is still rural, the domain of farmers and orchard owners. This is especially the case in District 4, where Chutipong secured his seat. He is a local man, but spent several years living in California. The province has for a long time been dominated by a single powerful clan, the Pitutecha family. This is what is termed in Thailand as "Baan Yai" – large household – politics, and throughout the country it is the manner provincial control has traditionally been maintained.
Pitutechas control a large part of the local government.
Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the present patriarch, is the chosen leader of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a extremely important post as the PAO manages the bulk of government spending in Rayong.
Until 2023, Pitutechas had invariably been included in the MPs chosen to parliament, with one serving as the deputy health minister in Bangkok.
Similar to other "Big House" dynasties they have no fixed affiliation – over time they have stood for five different political parties. They are also influential in the regional commercial sector, and, in contrast to Chutipong, have substantial funds to dispense. It was virtually hopeless for the first-time MP to challenge.
The "Baan Yai" rely on widespread systems of canvassers - residents who are familiar with their areas, and who rally voters to back their candidate. And although it is legally not allowed, they also hand out money before, during, and after elections. They have historically been vital to the electoral performance of provincial hopefuls, and as a recent, largely metropolitan organisation, the People's Party had did not possess them.
"Therefore I changed my tactics," says Chutipong. "I announced that I would seek to address all grievances promptly. If your water doesn't run, your electricity has failed, your road has damage, I would respond."
"But the locals who called me in then experienced intimidation from the established system. Some got criticised in the village's online forum or over the PA system in the village. They were charged of allowing me - a stranger they said - into the area."
"On occasions when I attempted to visit factories after hearing some allegations about contamination, I faced a hostile response from the community because they had been accepting envelopes from these factories."
During the latest election cycle, the Pitutechas had adjusted following their loss in the last election.
In those electoral areas, they ran junior members of the family, with higher education and with a reduced old-guard reputation than the established figures. In District 3 they ran under the Democrat party, traditionally their chosen political partner, but in District 4, thirty-four-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha campaigned under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, known for its substantial resources and its ability in recruiting "Baan Yai" over to his side.
Chutipong was outmatched.
The Pitutechas recaptured both seats back from the People's Party, while the progressives held onto three seats in Rayong.
"They might have accepted me if I had provided them money, but I would not be able to do that forever considering my limited resources. I had to decide whether I would be the representative they expected, or whether I would hold onto my values and find out if the constituents would